WorthAFollowHow to Score a Trader
How to Score a Trader
Score each category from 0 to 10 using public information, observed behavior, and evidence over time. The overall trader score is the average of the five categories.
Strong Follow Candidate
Clear, consistent, useful, and transparent. Worth studying closely.
Worth Studying
Generally useful and credible, but still worth verifying before relying on them.
Caution
Some value may be present, but key areas are unclear, inconsistent, or under-documented.
High Risk
Too many red flags, weak evidence, poor risk discussion, or low transparency.
The Trader Scorecard
The Trader Scorecard
Use the same categories shown on trader profile pages. Add a score from 0 to 10 for each category, then average the five scores.
| Category | What We Look For | Score | Notes / Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Clarity
How clear they are
|
Clear thesis, levels, invalidation, trade context, and reasoning that can be understood before or during the trade — not only after it works. | ||
|
Risk Awareness
How they manage risk
|
Discussion of invalidation, stops, position sizing, drawdowns, uncertainty, and capital protection instead of only upside targets. | ||
|
Consistency
How steady they are
|
A repeatable process over time, similar standards across posts, and behavior that does not depend on one hot streak or viral market call. | ||
|
Educational Value
What they teach
|
Real explanations, lessons, examples, market context, frameworks, and content that helps followers think better instead of blindly copy trades. | ||
|
Transparency
What they show
|
Open discussion of reasoning, mistakes, losses, limitations, updates, and whether past claims can be checked or reviewed later. | ||
| Overall Trader Score | /10 | ||
Manual scoring note: add the five category scores, then divide by 5. This keeps the scorecard aligned with WorthAFollow trader profile scores.
What Each Category Means
Clarity
How clearly the trader explains their idea, timeframe, levels, thesis, and invalidation.
Risk Awareness
How responsibly they discuss downside, position sizing, stops, drawdowns, and uncertainty.
Consistency
Whether their process, tone, expectations, and standards remain steady over time.
Educational Value
Whether they teach useful concepts and help followers improve instead of only chasing calls.
Transparency
How much they reveal about reasoning, mistakes, losses, updates, and performance context.
Red Flags That Lower the Score
Red Flags That Lower the Score
Hype Over Substance
Focuses on luxury, income claims, or hype instead of teaching and real process.
Lack of Transparency
No verifiable history, hidden results, deleted mistakes, or cherry-picked screenshots.
Poor Risk Management
No invalidation, no stops, oversized positions, or frequent unmanaged blow-ups.
Pressure & Promises
Pushy sales tactics, fake urgency, guaranteed returns, or pressure to copy blindly.
Find Traders Who Earn Your Trust.
Use the scorecard to evaluate any trader, then explore our vetted list of top traders who score high where it matters.